Chili’s Oldtimer Burger with Cheese Copycat Recipe

This Chili’s Oldtimer Burger with Cheese is a no-frills, straight-up beef burger that delivers exactly what the original does: a thick, juicy patty, melted American cheese, crisp lettuce, ripe tomato, and that tangy Thousand Island-style sauce on a toasted bun. If you want that diner-style burger at home without a trip to the restaurant, this is the recipe to make tonight.

It comes together in about 30 minutes with ingredients you likely already have on hand.

Why I Love This Recipe

The beef-to-bun ratio here is what keeps me coming back. A 6-oz patty is thick enough to stay juicy in the center while the outside gets a proper sear.

The sauce is the other thing. It’s sharp and slightly sweet, and it ties the whole burger together in a way plain ketchup never would.

This is the version I keep making because it’s genuinely simple and the result tastes like something you’d pay $14 for at a restaurant.

Recipe Ingredients

• 6 oz (170g) 80/20 ground beef per patty – The fat content keeps it juicy; leaner beef will give you a drier result
• 1 tsp kosher salt – For seasoning the patties
• ½ tsp black pepper – Freshly ground if you have it
• 1 slice American cheese per burger – Melts flat and smooth; cheddar works but behaves differently
• 1 brioche burger bun per burger – Toasts well and holds up to the sauce; any soft sesame bun works
• 1 tbsp unsalted butter – For toasting the buns
• 2 tbsp Thousand Island dressing – Store-bought is fine; this is the base of the burger sauce
• 1 tsp yellow mustard – Adds a sharper note to the sauce
• 1 tsp ketchup – Rounds out the sauce with a little sweetness
• 2 leaves green leaf lettuce per burger – Crisp and mild; iceberg works too
• 2 slices ripe tomato per burger – Cut about ¼-inch thick
• 4 to 5 dill pickle chips per burger – Adds the salty, briny bite the original has
• 2 tbsp white onion, finely diced – Raw, for a sharp contrast to the rich beef

Variations / Substitutions

• Swap American cheese for pepper jack – You get a mild heat and a creamier melt than cheddar.
• Use ground turkey instead of beef – The burger will be leaner and slightly firmer; go to medium heat to avoid drying it out.
• Make it dairy-free – Skip the butter and toast the bun dry in the pan; use a dairy-free cheese slice that melts well.
• Add heat to the sauce – Stir in ½ tsp hot sauce or a pinch of cayenne to the Thousand Island mixture for a spicier version.
• Swap the bun for a lettuce wrap – Two large iceberg leaves hold the patty and toppings well if you’re avoiding bread.
• Use red onion instead of white – It’s slightly milder raw and adds a bit of color.

If you enjoy making restaurant burgers at home, the Applebee’s Classic Burger Copycat Recipe follows a similar approach and is worth trying next.

How To Make Oldtimer Burger with Cheese

Step 1: Mix and Shape the Patties

Take the 6 oz (170g) portions of 80/20 ground beef and gently shape each one into a round patty about ¾-inch thick. Season both sides with the 1 tsp kosher salt and ½ tsp black pepper, pressing the seasoning lightly into the surface. Do not overwork the meat. The less you handle it, the more tender the result.

Press a small indent into the center of each patty with your thumb. It should be about the size of a quarter and roughly ¼-inch deep. This stops the patty from puffing up into a dome as it cooks.

Step 2: Stir the Burger Sauce

In a small bowl, combine the 2 tbsp Thousand Island dressing, 1 tsp yellow mustard, and 1 tsp ketchup. Stir until smooth and fully blended. Set aside at room temperature until you’re ready to build the burgers.

The sauce should be a pale orange-pink color and thick enough to coat the back of a spoon without running off immediately.

Step 3: Toast the Buns

Set a large skillet or cast-iron pan over medium heat. Add the 1 tbsp unsalted butter and let it melt and foam, about 1 minute. Place the buns cut-side down in the pan and press them lightly. Toast for about 2 minutes until the cut faces are golden brown with some darker spots at the edges. Remove them and set aside.

Step 4: Sear the Patties

Keep the same pan over medium-high heat. Add the shaped patties and cook for 3 to 4 minutes on the first side without pressing or moving them. You want a dark brown crust to form. Flip once and cook for another 2 to 3 minutes on the second side. In the last 30 seconds of cooking, lay 1 slice of American cheese on each patty and cover the pan with a lid. The cheese should be fully melted and slightly bubbling at the edges when you lift the lid.

The patty is done when the internal temperature reads 160°F (71°C) on an instant-read thermometer. The outside should be deeply browned with a little char at the edges.

Step 5: Build and Garnish the Burgers

Spread half the burger sauce on the bottom bun and the other half on the top bun. Layer 2 leaves of green leaf lettuce and 2 slices of ripe tomato on the bottom bun, then set the cheese-covered patty on top. Add the 4 to 5 dill pickle chips and the 2 tbsp finely diced white onion over the patty, then press the top bun down. Serve immediately on a wooden board or plate with the cross-section facing out so the melted cheese and stacked toppings are visible.

Recipe Tips

• Choose 80/20 beef, not leaner – The fat renders during cooking and keeps the inside moist. A 90/10 blend will cook up drier and tighter.
• Don’t skip the thumb indent – Without it, the center of the patty contracts and rises, leaving you with a thick dome that takes longer to cook through evenly.
• Season just before cooking, not ahead of time – Salt draws moisture out of the meat. If you season and then wait, the surface gets wet and you lose the crust.
• Use a hot pan, not a grill pan with ridges – The flat surface of a cast-iron or stainless skillet gives you more contact and a better crust than a ridged grill pan.
• Rest the patty for 2 minutes after cooking – The juices redistribute. Cut into it straight off the heat and they all run out onto the board.

Cook times by patty thickness:

How To Store

• Refrigerate – Store cooked patties in an airtight container for up to 3 days. Keep sauce, toppings, and buns separate or the bun will go soggy.
• Reheating – Reheat the patty in a skillet over medium heat for 2 to 3 minutes per side, or in a 350°F (175°C) oven for 8 to 10 minutes. Toast a fresh bun when reheating rather than reheating the original.

What To Serve With Oldtimer Burger with Cheese

Thin, crispy fries are the most natural pairing because their salt and crunch contrast with the rich, saucy patty. A side of coleslaw works well too since the acidity in the dressing cuts through the fat in the beef and cheese. If you want something lighter, a simple green salad with a sharp vinaigrette does the same job.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make the patties ahead of time?

Yes. Shape them up to 24 hours in advance and store them covered in the fridge. Season them right before they go into the pan, not before storing.

Can I cook these on an outdoor grill instead of a skillet?

Yes, a gas or charcoal grill works well over medium-high heat. Use the same times as the skillet, but watch for flare-ups from the fat dripping onto the coals.

What if I can’t find American cheese?

Provolone is the next closest option for flat, smooth melting. Cheddar melts but tends to separate and get greasy under high heat.

Can I double the recipe for a crowd?

Yes. The sauce scales up directly, so just multiply each ingredient by the number of burgers. Cook the patties in batches rather than crowding the pan, or they’ll steam instead of sear.

—

Oldtimer Burger with Cheese Recipe

Print Recipe Pin Recipe

Prep Time 10 minutes mins

Cook Time 2 minutes mins

Total Time 30 minutes mins

Servings: 2 servings

Ingredients Method Notes

Ingredients

  

• 12 oz (340g) 80/20 ground beef, divided into 2 patties of 6 oz each
• 1 tsp kosher salt
• ½ tsp black pepper
• 2 slices American cheese
• 2 brioche burger buns
• 1 tbsp unsalted butter
• 4 tbsp Thousand Island dressing
• 2 tsp yellow mustard
• 2 tsp ketchup
• 4 leaves green leaf lettuce
• 4 slices ripe tomato
• 8 to 10 dill pickle chips
• 4 tbsp white onion, finely diced

Method

 

1. Shape the ground beef into two 6 oz patties, each about ¾-inch thick. Season both sides with the kosher salt and black pepper and press a shallow thumb indent into the center of each.
2. Stir together the Thousand Island dressing, yellow mustard, and ketchup in a small bowl until smooth. Set aside.
3. Melt the butter in a skillet over medium heat and toast the buns cut-side down for about 2 minutes until golden. Remove and set aside.
4. Raise the heat to medium-high and cook the patties for 3 to 4 minutes on the first side, then flip and cook 2 to 3 minutes on the second side. In the last 30 seconds, place a slice of American cheese on each patty, cover the pan, and let it melt. Rest the patties for 2 minutes.
5. Spread the sauce on both cut sides of each bun. Layer the lettuce and tomato on the bottom bun, add the patty, then top with the pickle chips and diced white onion. Press the top bun on and serve immediately.

Notes

These patties are best cooked and eaten right away, but you can shape them and keep them covered in the fridge for up to 24 hours before cooking. Make the sauce at the same time you shape the patties to save yourself a step when it’s time to cook. The thumb indent in the center is a small detail that makes a noticeable difference in how evenly the patty cooks through.